Classic Car Insurance

Classic car insurance for Florida collectors

Coverage that reflects what your car is worth, explained by one dedicated agent.

We compare collector car policies across the companies we represent, explain how each one values and protects your car, and leave the decision to you.

Coverage

Classic Car Insurance coverage explained

  • Agreed value

    Sets the car's insured value up front, so you know what a total loss would pay.

  • Liability

    Helps pay for injuries and damage you cause to others while driving.

  • Collision

    Helps repair or replace the car after a crash with a vehicle or object.

  • Comprehensive

    Covers theft, fire, storm damage and other non-crash losses, including in storage.

  • Uninsured motorist

    Helps cover your injuries when the other driver has no insurance or too little.

  • Spare parts

    Covers the spare and original parts you keep for the car.

Who this coverage is for

Classic car insurance is for vehicles kept for enjoyment, not daily transportation: restored classics, antiques, muscle cars, exotics and newer collector models.

Many owners come to us because the car is on a regular auto policy that treats it like any used car. Others have finished a restoration or added a car to the collection and want it valued properly.

Choosing your coverage

The most important decision is the value. An agreed value is set with the insurance company when the policy starts, so it helps to have photos, receipts and an appraisal if you have one. Review it every year or two, since collector values change.

Next, be realistic about how you use the car. These policies are priced for limited driving, such as shows, club events and pleasure drives.

If the car is still being restored, ask about coverage that raises its value as the work progresses.

Florida

Florida considerations

A classic car registered in Florida needs the same required coverage as any other car, even if you drive it only a few times a year.

Storm season is the other consideration. Where the car is stored, and whether that building could flood, matters more here than in most states.

Common gaps

Common gaps we see in Classic Car Insurance policies

Many people believe they're adequately insured—until a claim reveals otherwise. Policies are often purchased quickly, renewed automatically, and rarely reviewed as risks change or costs rise.

Some of the most common gaps we identify include:

  • Insured on a regular auto policy that pays a depreciated value

  • Agreed value not updated after restoration work or a rise in market value

  • Usage limits that don't match how the car is driven

  • Spare parts, tools and trailers left off the policy

These gaps often stay hidden until a claim brings them to light. Our goal is to address them before that happens.

Our approach

How we help you get the right coverage

  1. Assess your needs

    You tell us about your situation and what matters to you.

  2. Compare options

    Your agent lines up quotes from several insurance companies and explains the differences.

  3. Secure coverage

    You choose what fits. The same agent stays with you afterwards.

An agent talking with a client

Why work with Right Choice Insurance

  • Independent

    We work for you, not for one insurance company.

  • Multiple companies

    One conversation gets you options from several insurers.

  • One dedicated agent

    You keep the same agent for questions, changes and renewals.

  • Based in Southwest Florida

    A Fort Myers office serving all of Florida.

FAQ

Classic Car Insurance questions

What counts as a classic car?

It varies by company. Most look at the car's age, its condition and how it is used. Antiques, restored classics, muscle cars, exotics and some newer collector models can all qualify.

Can I use my classic car as a daily driver?

Usually not. Collector policies are meant for limited pleasure use, and most companies ask that you have another vehicle for everyday driving.

Does the car have to be kept in a garage?

Most companies expect a locked garage or similar secure storage. Tell us where the car is kept, and we'll check which companies accept it.

What do I need to get a quote?

The year, make, model and VIN, a few current photos, the value you have in mind, and where the car is stored.

Coverage support

Have a question about a policy you already have, or ready to compare options? Your agent can help with either.

Get a quote

Share how you’d like us to reach you, and an agent will follow up with options.

This field is required.
What do you want to protect?
This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.
How should we contact you?
This field is required.
Best time