Fort Myers, FL(239) 313-2045
Proud Franchise of We Insure
Skip to Main

Start Your Quote

Share a few details, and we’ll guide you to coverage that fits your needs.

This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.
What type of insurance are you looking for?
This field is required.
What type of auto coverage?
What type of property?
This field is required.
This field is required.
What type of business coverage?
This field is required.
This field is required.
Do you currently have insurance?
.
Preferred Contact Method
This field is required.
Best Time to Contact

About Right Choice Insurance

Your Trusted Partner in Protection

Right Choice Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving Florida families and businesses. We believe everyone deserves clear, honest guidance when it comes to protecting what matters most.

Insurance agent consulting with clients about coverage options in professional office setting
Contact Us →

Our Story

15+ Years of Putting Clients First

Founded in Florida, Right Choice Insurance was built on a simple idea: insurance should protect people, not confuse them. Too many families and business owners were left guessing about their coverage, overwhelmed by jargon, and unsure if they were truly protected.

We set out to change that. As an independent agency, we work with over 20 top-rated carriers to find the right fit for each client — not the right fit for a single insurance company. That independence means we can offer honest recommendations, competitive rates, and coverage tailored to your real needs.

  • 15+

    Years Experience

  • 2,500+

    Clients

  • 75+

    Carries

  • 100%

    Client Focused

Our values

What Guides Us Every Day

  • Relationships Over Transactions

    We're not here to sell you a policy and disappear. We build lasting relationships and provide ongoing support whenever you need us.

  • Clarity Over Confusion

    Insurance is complicated enough. We explain your options in plain language so you can make informed decisions without the industry jargon.

  • Your Interest First

    As an independent agency, we represent you—not a single carrier. We recommend what protects you best, not what pays us most.

Why Independent?

The Advantage of Choice

Unlike captive agents who work for a single insurance company, we work for you. Our independence means we can shop the market, compare rates from multiple carriers, and find coverage that truly fits your situation.

  • Access to 75+ top-rated insurance carriers
  • Unbiased recommendations based on your needs
  • Competitive rates through carrier comparison
  • One point of contact for all your policies